Semis Framework Test (Bliss + Dustin)
Attendees: Dustin J Ross, Bliss Perry Date: February 5, 2026 Type: Partner Session
Summary
Meeting Setup & Agenda
- Started late due to scheduling confusion (thought 1:30 vs 1:00)
- Extended meeting by 15 minutes to 2:50 PM hard stop
- Success criteria: Develop up to 3 hypotheses for testing with remaining 4 supply chains
- Agenda: Share insights → Deep dive analysis → Concrete product hypotheses → Next steps
Key Insights from Semiconductor Analysis
Bliss’s Three Insights:
- Complexity vs. Resilience Distinction
- Complex supply chains aren’t necessarily unresilient
- Semis have structural bottlenecks: geographic concentration, high CapEx, human capital constraints, high lock-in
- Oil comparison: complex but flexible (can reroute, blend sources, move refineries)
- Resilience as Public Good
- Foundries absorb shocks by passing prices to customers due to market power
- No incentive for proactive resilience investment without compensation
- Government subsidies currently only mechanism driving resilience projects
- Market-Driven Resilience Opportunities
- Missing mechanisms that exist in oil: OPEC-style coordination, futures markets, demand indexes, strategic reserves
- Concept: “Resilience as a Service” (RAS)
Dustin’s Three Insights:
- Value Chain vs Supply Chain Focus
- Many value-additive opportunities don’t touch physical supply chain
- Framework shift needed from supply to value chain thinking
- Financial/Logistical Infrastructure Gap
- Semis principally lag in financial and logistical mechanisms
- Need to quantify volatility including 2020s chip shortage
- Automotive as MVP Candidate
- Hit hardest by chip shortage, understands pain
- Likely willing to pay for solutions
Financial Products as Core Opportunity
- ChatGPT analysis identified missing layers: commodity trading, risk hedging, insurance, strategic buffering, capital formation, market intelligence
- All opportunities except strategic buffering are financial products
- One data product (market intelligence) similar to initial proposal
- Potential to build fintech/financial-first solution rather than pure supply chain tool
Specific Product Hypotheses Discussed
- Semiconductor Commodity Exchange & Hedging Platform
- High potential but very difficult execution
- Independent Trading House (“Glencore of Chips”)
- Challenges: chips aren’t fungible, depreciate over time, Moore’s law effects
- Question: Does Moore’s law death make chips more commoditized?
- Insurance & Risk Solutions
- Multiple types: business interruption, parametric, yield/output, political risk
- Example: Chip continuity insurance for automakers (20% delivery shortfall triggers payout)
- Requires actuarial modeling and projections
- SageSure model: issue policies, sell to insurers, no liability held
- Real-Time Supply Chain Intelligence Platform
- “Waze for chip supply chain” - crowdsourced information sharing
- Marketplace for excess inventory swapping
- Risk monitoring and alternative sourcing suggestions
Data Strategy & Business Model
- All financial products built on same underlying data asset
- Eric Schmidt model: collect data through one service, monetize across multiple products
- Entry point strategy: use one service to accumulate data capital, expand to other services
- Potential path: Intelligence platform → Trading → Commodity exchange → Full financial ecosystem
Critical Research Questions
- Is there actual volatility or just perpetual undersupply?
- Daily volatility vs. black swan events?
- Supply/demand yo-yo like oil, or structural shortage for next 40 years?
Next Steps & Assignments
Dustin’s Homework:
- Study 2022 semiconductor shortage as case study
- One-page summary of what happened
- Understand fundamental industry volatility patterns
- Compare/contrast with oil industry dynamics
Bliss’s Homework:
- Define optimal data asset requirements
- Economic lens: what’s the most valuable data?
- What high-value decisions need data-informed support?
- How to incentivize data sharing?
- Test framework against 3 other supply chains for verification